*New*
 Rigged trials
 Legal Letter
 GM Crops: Risks and Risk Management Required
 Agronomics and Economics of GM Canola

1. Key issues
 Summary and Overview
 10 main NCF concerns
 Farmers misled
 Q & A for school projects
 What is the drive for GM crops?
 Links to other issues
 Scientific concerns summary
 The future - 2020?
 What is expected of non-GM growers in Canada
 Beyond the Bulldust
 *Unfair liability*
 Pressures in GM debate
 Questions regarding risk management
 Genetic engineering – a crop of hyperbole
 Agronomics and Economics of GM canola

2. GM crops banned
 Monsanto Crop Management & Resistance Management Plans
 Why Australia is not prepared for commercial trials
 Monsanto's GM Roundup Ready canola
 Bayer Cropscience's GM Invigor canola
 Where to now?
 State legislation - moratoria

3. Market issues
 Canola markets
 Zero tolerance of GM contamination is market demand
 Wheat will be impacted
 Higher prices for non-GM canola
 Contamination scare affects market
 Japanese requirements
 Consumer polls & market rejection
 Effects of GM contamination in canola
 EU will not tolerate acceptance of tolerance levels
 What our marketers say
 How and when non-GM premiums started

About us
 Network Policy & Objectives
 NCF Funding
 NCF History
 NCF profile: Julie Newman
 NCF profile: Juliet McFarlane
 Early work

Canola
 What is canola?
 Statistics - yields
 GM Canola Factsheet
 Canadian farmers nervous about GM canola acceptance in Japan
 Letter from Japan

Coexistence & Segregation
 Crop Management Plans for non-GM grower
 Farmer to farmer Hypothetical
 Segregation and coexistence plans
 Seed industry allows 0.5% contamination
 Canadian grain segregation
 Zero tolerance is market demand
 European coexistence report
 Identity preservation and segregation
 What is expected of non-GM growers in Canada
 Testing protocol
 Labels for GM contamination
 EU will not accept contamination
 Proposed Stewardship Program for Canola
 Contract harvester problems
 Crop management plans
 Industry avoids the truth about GM segregation

Consumer concerns
 Is GM food safe?
 Churches - 10 reasons against GM
 Scientific concerns
 Cross Kingdom Breeding
 Food safety testing inadequate
 Environmental effects
 13 Science based reasons for GM-free
 Myths about the Digestion of Proteins and DNA
 5 part series covering issues
 Health Risk
 Reason for Schools to ban GM Foods
 Monsanto's feeding studies
 FSANZ answers regarding food testing
 Scientific report on safety testing
 Trespass report
 Scientific concerns
 Consumer concerns summary
 GM food lecture
 Monsanto
 Seeds of Concern
 Public attitudes to GM food
 Scrambling and gambling with the genome
 L-tryptophan - A Deadly Epidemic
 Protestors (photos)
 GM health concerns in brief
 Inadequate health testing for GM canola
 Russian study showing high death rates in offspring
 Pusztai debate
 Hidden uncertainties - risks of GMOs
 Study shows GM eating Americans sicker than non-GM eating English
 Scientists see spike in kids' food allergies
 Latest GMO Research: Decreased Fertility, Immunological Alterations and Allergies
 Key health papers of concern
 Do we really know what we are doing?

Contamination
 Contamination is uncontrollable (photos)
 Gene transfer & cross-pollination
 GM product recalls
 Environmental contamination (photos)
 Confronting contamination & co-existence
 Invigor canola outcrossing
 Gene Stacking = Super Weed
 AOF contamination report
 History of how Bayer Cropscience caused contamination of non-GM canola in Australia
 Fighting GMO contamination around the world

Corporate control
 Corporate control
 Corporate Engineering in Public Debate
 Commercial influence on science
 In (Seed) Bed Together
 The drive behind GM Crops
 Cartoon
 IP And Genetically Modified Organisms: A Fateful Combination
 Commercial influence on science
 Made by Monsanto

Costs and liabilities
 Costs to non-GM farmers
 Non-GM Liable for Contamination?
 Liability issues associated with GM crops - AFFA
 Supplying non-GM requires certification
 Liability questions answered
 More on liability
 *Farmer liability*
 Liability and GM crops

Economics
 No economic benefit for farmers
 Economic Recommendations
 Economic Critique
 Why has the OGTR ignored economics?
 Australian farmers can not afford GM crops
 What benefit?
 Higher plant yields better or worse for farmers?
 Effects of GM contamination in canola
 Global seed industry concentration
 Canada versus Australia comparison
 No farmer economic gain for pharmaceutical crops
 NCF: Economics of GM canola ***
 Agronomics and Economics of GM Canola

Farmer attitudes
 Australian farmer surveys
 Farm lobby group policies
 Victorian ALP policy
 GCA farm lobby group policies

GM / Non-GM difference
 What is GM / Non-GM?
 GM plant breeding not faster
 Will the industry be in crisis without GM?
 Why GM is different
 Non-GM biotech is the future

GM canola
 Will GM canola yield more in Australia?
 Comparison between Canadian and Australian canola conditions
 Are GM chemicals safer, cheaper or more efficient?
 How much GM canola is grown in Canada?
 Canadian and Australian canola statistics
 Economics of GM canola

GM crops
 Public good or corporate control?
 Misleading claims over GM
 ISAAA GM crop areas misleading
 Use of GM crops
 GM crops and chemical use
 Multiple spray applications vs yield penalty
 Yield problems - links
 GM cotton failures
 Global yields
 Pharmaceutical crops
 Global Trends in GM Crops
 Who benefits from GM crops?

GM crops experience
 Canadian Farmers viewpoint
 American farmers viewpoint
 American Corn Growers experience
 Argentina faces serious problems
 Report on North American Experience
 Canadian organic farmers
 Argentina & GM soy - success at what cost?
 How is industry managing non-GM now?
 India, Bulgaria, Indonesia
 Monsanto vs US farmers
 Global GM adoption
 US farmers warned of GM Liability
 Farming news links
 GM-growing US faces agricultural trade deficit
 GM soy in US not considered food grade
 Monsanto in Argentina
 GM soy war in Paraguay
 Violence in Brazil
 12 Years of GM soya in Argentina - disaster for people and environment

GM wheat
 Learn more about GM wheat
 Marketing systems for GM wheat
 GM Wheat submission - food health
 Report - Farmers lose with GM wheat
 What our marketers say
 Canadian Wheat Board position
 GM Wheat impossible to segregate

Honey issues
 Apiarist briefing
 The impact of GM contamination
 SA Apiarists briefing
 Map SA & Vic
 Honey tests reveal GM contamination

How trustworthy is decision-making?
 Vested interests revealed
 Why trust the regulatory process?
 Sue Meek profile
 Federal government pro-GM
 Scientists influenced
 Liability, GCA and legal action
 Research manipulated
 OGTR does not assess economics, segregation, chemical resistance, food testing etc.
 Three faces of science fraud
 Misleading GM language

Insurance
 Insurance Council submission
 Insurance avoid GM risk

International Protocols
 World Trade Organisation
 Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety
 Free Trade Agreement
 Farmers right to replant seeds
 International agreements
 GM labelling
 WTO ruling does not prevent countries from restricting or banning GMOs
 Biotechnology Policy Documents of FAO Members

Legal Issues
 Law
 Copy of Technology User Agreement
 2003 Monsanto contract
 GM Patents
 Monsanto shoot themselves in the foot (cartoon)
 Will law protect us from contamination?
 Summary of Supreme Court hearing of Percy Schmeiser
 NSW Minister guarantees farmers are protected
 AFFA-liability issues
 US farmers sued
 US farmers warned of GM liability issues
 GM Crops and farmers Liability
 Why is the non-GM grower liable for contamination?
 Innocent farmer sued
 Federal judge's opinion shows understanding of patented gene spread
 Liability for non-GM farmers
 More on liability:
 Liability and GM crops
 Farmers prepare for legal fight over GM
 Legal letter from non-GM to GM
 Liability issues - Duncan Currie

Legislation & Regulation
 Trials vs Commercial Release
 Bayer Cropscience Invigor Canola approved by OGTR
 States impose moratoriums in role to protect economics
 OGTR role
 Gene Technology Act
 GM canola trial locations
 Victorian Moratorium
 Australian GM status by States
 Federal candidate views
 OGTR unapproved GM canola trials
 Gene Technology Act Critique
 South Australian Act
 WA proudly GM-free
 *State moratoria legislation*
 Gene Tech Act reviews denies compensation
 National Biotechnology Strategy
 Chronology of genetic engineering regulation in Australia: 1953–2008

Links
 Genome Scrambling Links
 Links
 Top 10 books on GM
 Religious links

Network action
 Invigor canola submission OGTR
 GM Zone proposal submissions
 GTGC submission summary
 NCF Newsletters
 NCF Media releases
 GTGC full submission
 Roundup Ready Submission OGTR
 Network tours
 pro-GM lobbyists attack NCF
 Pro-GM tantrums
 Advertisement
 Victorian farmer survey
 NCF banner & flyer
 Field day survey
 Community monitoring of GM Crop Trials
 Letters to farmers
 
 Gene Tech Act Review Pt1
 Gene Tech Act Reveiw Pt 2
 Gene Tech Act Review Pt3
 Bayer Protest
 Bayers Response to NCF
 NCF submission released

Organics
 Canadian organic standard
 American organic standards

Trials
 Victorian maps
 Victorian sites - photos
 SA trial photos
 Trials summary
 Topas 19/2 contamination
 South Australia 2006 GM Trials

 

30 August 2005

What is expected of non-GM growers in Canada

The following procedures are expected of a non-GM grower if GM is introduced. The question is why a non-GM farmer should be expected to go to such outrageous and expensive lengths to avoid GM contamination. Surely the principle of coexistence should be to ensure the GM grower contained their product, not that the non-GM grower should avoid their product.

The protocols would not even be possible in Australia as already the seed industry has claimed they will allow a 0.5% contamination in non-GM seed. It is very obvious that every effort is being made in Australia to ensure non-GM growers can not market as non-GM.

Julie Newman, Network of Concerned Farmers

----

Ontario Ministry of Agriculture Food and Rural Affairs

Author: Hugh Martin - Organic Crop Production Program Lead/OMAF

Creation Date: June 2004

Last Reviewed: June 2004

There are many market opportunities for non-GMO crops. Growers need to practice due diligence to reduce or eliminate the presence of material from genetically modified organisms (GMO's) in the final product. The amount of GMO content that is allowed will be dictated by the contract or the purchaser according to their end markets requirements. Non-GMO markets include organic production and many food grade markets.

As a grower you have two possible situations:

You are growing non-GMO crops and selling into non-GMO markets. If you do not meet the non-GMO market requirements you will lose that market premium. It will cost you profit and harm your opportunity for those markets in the future.

Your neighbour is growing non-GMO crops and your practices (from your GMO crops) may impact on their ability to market acceptable non-GMO crop products.

Here are some strategies to maximize your opportunities in the non-GMO markets.

Use GMO-free seed. Make sure that the seed you use was not inadvertently contaminated by GMO material. Certified seed has been grown and processed according to accepted standards to maintain crop purity. Keep records of seed sources. Some markets, such as organic, require a letter from the seed supplier declaring the non-GMO status of the seed.

Grow non-GMO crops in fields that are properly isolated from neighboring fields (even small fields/gardens) of GMO crops of the same species. Know the required distances for your crop. Know which varieties are GMO and which events may be problematic for your market. Staggering corn planting (and pollination) dates can help, but this is not a foolproof method of eliminating contamination.

Establish good lines of communication and work with your neighbours to negotiate field selection and to minimize future surprises. This should be done well in advance with a last minute update at planting time.

Know which neighbouring crops are GMO with the potential for contamination of your crops. Record the locations and distances to your crops. For corn and canola record the pollination dates of each field.

Make sure your equipment, (planters, combines, grain buggies, trucks, augers, and bins) is clean when handling seed and grain. If possible, do not use the same equipment for GMO and non-GMO crops. Clean all equipment thoroughly, especially custom equipment. Record procedures used to clean and check equipment.

Do not contaminate grain with dust or other crop materials from GMO crops when handling, trucking or processing.

Test your crop for the presence of GMO and keep these records. Keep a sample of the product at time of sale in case future testing is required.

Know what your buyers want - before you plant.

Keep complete and accurate records to establish an audit trail, in case they are required in the future.

Adapted from "10 Strategies to Minimize Risks of GMO Contamination" by Jim Riddle, Organic Independents, Winona, MN

Related Links:

10 Strategies to Minimize Risks of GMO Contamination

10 Strategies to Minimize Risks of GMO Contamination

by James A. Riddle

Organic Independents, Winona, MN

1. Know your seeds – Prior to planting, verify that non-GMO seeds will be used. Obtain statements from

seed companies concerning the non-GMO status of the varieties to be planted. Have seeds tested for all

applicable GMO “events”. Retain copies of test results and letters from seed suppliers.

2. Know your farm – Know your fields and determine which have the lowest risk of GMO contamination.

Select isolated fields for wind and/or insect pollinated crops (corn, canola). Know the prevailing wind

direction. Establish physical buffers, such as windbreaks and hedgerows.

3. Know your neighbors – Establish good lines of communication with neighbors, especially those who

directly adjoin organic fields. Notify them that you are an organic farmer, and where your organic fields are

located. Get to know farmers who farm adjoining fields, even if they rent the land. Post “Organic Farm” signs

along field margins, where needed.

4. Know your neighbors’ crops – Gather information from neighbors, seed dealers, and farm input suppliers

on the types of crops being grown in the vicinity. Know which GMO events are being planted. If neighbors

are growing Bt crops, ask them to plant their “20% non-Bt refuges” in areas that adjoin organic fields, to

provide some buffer protection. If possible, delay your planting dates so that your organic crops do not

pollinate at the same time as GMO crops.

5. Know your equipment – Know what your equipment is used for. This includes rented and borrowed

equipment and equipment used by custom operators. Know how to clean all pieces of equipment, including

planters, combines, wagons, trucks, etc. Clean equipment prior to use in organic fields, and keep records to

document your equipment cleaning activities.

6. Know your harvest – Submit samples prior to harvest for GMO testing. If contamination is likely, collect

samples along a grid pattern, going from areas with the highest risk to areas with low risk. Submit the samples

separately, in case part, but not all, of the field is contaminated. Make sure samples are tested for all

applicable GMO events. Keep copies of test results.

7. Know your crop storage – Carefully inspect storage units prior to use. Dust from GMO crops can

contaminate organic crops. Thoroughly clean augers, bins, grain dryers, rotary screen cleaners, etc., especially

if they might have previously been used for GMO crops.

8. Know your truckers – Carefully inspect and clean trucks and trailers prior to loading with organic grain.

Make sure that transport units, including overseas shipping containers, are free of grain, dust, and other

foreign material. Keep records to document, including clean transportation affidavits and bills of lading.

9. Know your records – Document your efforts to minimize GMO contamination. With good records, you

will have a better chance of limiting losses, identifying causes of problems, and determining liability. Valid

records of organic yields and sales may help establish claims for losses, should contamination occur.

10. Know your buyers – Know the contract specifications under which the organic crop is being grown.

Know your buyer’s sampling and testing protocols. Know the market-driven GMO rejection levels

(tolerances) for the crops grown. Communicate with buyers and organic certifying agents concerning GMO

contamination issues.

Print Version
 

Seach the archive:  
or by date  

09 November 2009
Industry avoid the truth about GM segregation problems

11 June 2009
Dupont alleges anti-competitive conduct by Monsanto

24 February 2009
Non-GM Farmers to pay for unwanted GM contamination

02 February 2009
Made by Monsanto

01 February 2009
Top 10 Seed and Pesticide companies

29 January 2009
Agronomics and Economics of GM Canola

29 January 2009
Non-GM biotech is the future

26 January 2009
12 Yrs of GM soya in Argentina - disaster for people and environment

19 January 2009
Non-GM seed preferred by farmers but difficult to obtain

16 January 2009
GM Canola a flop

News archive